Civil Eats

Civil Eats is a California-based left-of-center food and food-policy publication that promotes claims critical of some industrial agriculture practices, such as the general administration of antibiotics to livestock and, in some cases, the genetic modification of crops. In addition to publishing its own independent content, the organization also publishes content funded by third-party organizations.

At-A-Glance

Website: civileats.com
CEO:

Naomi Starkman

Location: Cotati, CA View on map
Tax ID: 84-4826419
Most Recent Filing: 2024
Budget (2024): Assets: $1,573,563 Revenue: $1,072,511 Expenses: $1,128,228

Contents

    Background

    Civil Eats was founded in 2009 by Naomi Starkman, who remains with the organization as chairman of the board, CEO, and editor-in-chief, as well as Paula Crossfield, who remains with the organizations as an editor-at-large. Later in May 2020, the organization was registered as a charitable nonprofit organization in Coati, California. 1 2 3 4

    Activity

    Civil Eats publishes articles about food and food policy from a left-of-center perspective. Often, the organization publishes material focusing on aspects of the food industry geared to sway consumer behavior or support stricter regulations on agriculture and food production. The organization has published material highlighting claims of dangers associated with the use of antibiotics in livestock; criticizing the use of genetically modified crops, for instance, those used as inputs in the production of emulsifiers; and condemning the use of heavily processed meat-based slurries. 5

    Editorial Policy

    According to its website, though Civil Eats had adopted standards of “editorial independence” and “retains full authority over editorial content,” the organization also publishes material “with funding from outside parties.” The organization notes that some of the material it publishes, which it presents with the phrasing, “underwritten by,” is funded by third parties and is “editorially independent.” However, the organization notes that even such material undergoes a review process involving editors assessing a given piece’s suitability, with the final say resting with the editor-in-chief. 1

    Leadership

    Naomi Starkman is a founder, the editor-in-chief, and the CEO of Civil Eats. Previously, she was a 2016 John S. Knight journalism fellow at Stanford University and the deputy executive director of the City of San Francisco’s Ethics Commission. Additionally, Starkman has worked as a consultant to media companies including Newsweek, The New Yorker, Vanity Fair, GQ, WIRED, and Consumer Reports. 2

    Matthew Wheeland is the managing editor of Civil Eats. Previously, he worked as the managing editor of GreenBiz and AlterNet. 2

    Will Rosenzweig is the chairperson of the Civil Eats board of directors as well as the faculty director of the Sustainable Food Initiative at the Haas School of Business at the University of California, Berkeley. Previously, he was the managing partner of Physic Ventures, a health and wellness-oriented venture capital firm. 6 7

    Funding

    According to the Civil Eats website, organizations that have provided support to Civil Eats include the First Nations Development Institute, Grace Communications, Joyce & Irving Goldman Foundation, Ida and Robert Gordon Family Foundation, Hunter Grubb Foundation, Merck Family Fund, Nell Newman Foundation, NewsMatch, New Venture Fund, Panta Rhea Foundation, Elizabeth R. & William J. Patterson Foundation, Jay Pritzker Foundation, William Rosenzweig & Carla Fracchia, Sharon, Schendel Giving Fund, Schmidt Family Foundation, Sye Fund, and the TomKat Educational Fund. 8

    Financial Statistics

    Total Assets

    Total Revenue

    Total Expenses

    YearTotal AssetsTotal RevenueTotal ExpensesFiling
    2024 $1,573,563 $1,072,511 $1,128,228 View
    2023 $1,628,254 $1,288,262 $954,417 View
    2022 $1,289,484 $720,884 $803,695 View
    2021 $1,374,676 $574,439 $647,535 View
    2020 $1,437,772 $1,868,872 $431,100 View

    Revenue Detail

    Expenses Detail

    Employee Compensation

    • Number of Employees: 11

    Highest Earning Employees

    EmployeeTitleTotal Compensation
    Naomi StarkmanCEO President of the Board$150,750
    Matthew WheelandDirector of Operations$120,750
    Margo TrueEditorial Director$100,750

    Grant Activity

    All-time grants received statistics from Candid dataset:

    • Total Grant Value: $4,261,318
    • Number of Grants: 103
    • Number of Funders: 36

    Selection of highest value grants received from the last seven years:

    AmountYearFunderSubject
    $900,0002020 Sustainable Markets FoundationAGRICULTURE
    $250,0002024 The Chicago Community TrustGeneral support for programs, operations and other charitable purposes
    $200,0002024 The Schmidt Family FoundationWorking towards a resilient and equitable food system
    $175,0002023 The Chicago Community TrustGeneral Operating Support
    $175,0002022 The Chicago Community TrustGeneral operating support of Civil Eats.
    $150,0002023 The Schmidt Family FoundationCapacity building for partners
    $150,0002023 The Schmidt Family FoundationWorking towards a resilient and equitable food system
    $134,6002021 Sustainable Markets FoundationAGRICULTURE
    $100,0002024 Vanguard CharitableFOR RECIPIENT'S EXEMPT PURPOSE
    $100,0002023 Vanguard CharitableFOR RECIPIENT'S EXEMPT PURPOSE
    $100,0002023 The Elizabeth R & William J Patterson FoundationGeneral & Unrestricted
    $100,0002022 Vanguard CharitableFor recipient's exempt purpose
    $100,0002022 The Elizabeth R & William J Patterson FoundationGeneral & Unrestricted
    $100,0002021 The Chicago Community TrustGENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT
    $100,0002021 The Schmidt Family FoundationWorking towards a resilient and equitable food system
    $100,0002021 The Elizabeth R & William J Patterson FoundationGeneral & Unrestricted
    $100,0002021 Vanguard CharitableFOR RECIPIENT'S EXEM
    $100,0002020 The Schmidt Family FoundationWorking towards a resilient and equitable food system
    $100,0002020 The Elizabeth R & William J Patterson FoundationGeneral & Unrestricted
    $60,0002022 Panta Rhea Foundationgeneral support
    $52,5002024 Community Foundation for San Benito CountySTANDARD
    $52,5002023 Community Foundation for San Benito CountySTANDARD
    $50,0002023 Clif Family FoundationTransform Food Systems
    $50,0002023 First Nations Development InstituteECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
    $50,0002022 Community Foundation for San Benito CountyGENERAL

    References

    1. “About.” Civil Eats. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://civileats.com/about/
    2. “Who We Are.” Civil Eats. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://civileats.com/about/who-we-are/
    3. “Authors: Paula Crossfield.” Civil Eats. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://civileats.com/author/pcrossfield/
    4. “Civil Eats.” ProPublica. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/844826419
    6. “Board of Directors.” Civil Eats. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://civileats.com/about/board-of-directors/
    7. Civil Eats. Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax. (Form 990), 2021. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/844826419/202231969349300133/full
    8. “Supporters.” Civil Eats. Accessed November 27, 2023. https://civileats.com/about/supporters/