Contents
The ICRC has admitted failures related to its conduct during the Second World War and the Holocaust. Peter Maurer, a former president of the ICRC, admitted in 2015 that the organization had “failed to protect civilians and, most notably, Jews persecuted and murdered by the Nazi regime” during the Holocaust, adding that the ICRC “failed as a humanitarian organization” because it had “lost its moral compass.” François Bugnion, a former ICRC Director for International Law and Cooperation, stated in a 2002 article that there was “no doubt that senior ICRC officials had become aware of the genocide by the summer of 1942.” 2 3 In 2007, Argentina handed over the travel document issued by the ICRC used by Adolf Eichmann, one of the main architects of the Holocaust, to escape Europe after the end of the war. The ICRC has also admitted that at least ten leading Nazi war criminals were able to flee capture and prosecution after the war and escape to Argentina using documentation provided by the ICRC. 2 4
The International Committee of the Red Cross is an international humanitarian aid organization based in Geneva, Switzerland. The organization was founded in February 1863, and in 1864, it persuaded governments to adopt the first Geneva Convention, a treaty requiring armies to tend to wounded soldiers, no matter their allegiance, and introduced the Red Cross insignia, a red cross on a white background, as a unified emblem representing medical services protected from military targeting. 1
The ICRC expanded its work to establish national societies, the first of which was formed in Germany in November 1863. As of February 2026, the Red Cross and Red Crescent (the symbol used in Muslim countries) movement consists of the ICRC, 191 national societies based in nearly every country in the world, and the International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, a representative body of the national societies. National societies work in partnership with public authorities based on national and international laws. 1 5
During the First World War, the ICRC opened the International Prisoners of War Agency in Geneva to assist in restoring contact between captured military personnel and their families. The ICRC persuaded governments to adopt a new Geneva Convention in 1929, which provided greater protections to prisoners of war. 1
During World War II, the ICRC assisted in shipping relief supplies around the world to help prisoners of war and civilians. ICRC delegates also visited prisoners of war around the world, although the organization states that World War II was its “greatest failure” due to “a lack of action on behalf of victims of the Holocaust and other persecuted groups.” 1
At the ICRC’s initiative in 1949, governments agreed to revise the three Geneva Conventions in action at the time, covering the wounded on the battlefield, prisoners of war, and victims of war at sea. Nations also agreed to add a fourth Geneva Convention, which aimed to protect civilians living under hostile control. 1
The ICRC also implemented two Additional Protocols relating to the Geneva Convention in 1977. These protocols, one relating to international conflict and the other to non-international conflict, added additional rules to the conduct of hostilities. 1
The ICRC has a mandate that enables it to protect people affected by armed conflict and other violence. The mandate was given to ICRC under the four Geneva Conventions of 1949, the Additional Protocols of 1977 and 2005, as well as the Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement of 1986. This enables the ICRC to act independently of governments. 6
According to its website, the ICRC has more than 18,000 members of staff at its headquarters and in the field. 7
The International Committee of the Red Cross has faced criticism for its lack of action during the Holocaust, 2 and it and its officials have acknowledged substantial failures. Peter Maurer, a former president of the ICRC, admitted in 2015 that the organization had “failed to protect civilians and, most notably, Jews persecuted and murdered by the Nazi regime,” adding that the ICRC “failed as a humanitarian organization” because it had “lost its moral compass.” 2
Carl Jacob Burckhardt, vice president of the organization in the 1930s, attended the 1936 Olympic Games in Berlin and was invited to the Nazi Party’s annual rally in Nuremberg in 1937. Burckhardt also personally inspected the Dachau concentration camp in 1938, as part of a Nazi effort to reassure public opinion on the treatment of people and living conditions in the camps. The ICRC, in an official statement following Burckhardt’s tour, said, “We must recognise, in all objectivity, that the Dachau camp is a model of its kind in terms of the way it is built and managed.” 2
Historians have also concluded, after examining ICRC documents, that the organization knew about the “Final Solution of the Jewish Question,” the Nazi policy to murder the entire European Jewish population, since the spring of 1942, although the ICRC neither intervened to stop nor publicly condemned the existence of extermination camps. 2 8 3
Francois Bugnion, a former ICRC director for International Law and Cooperation, stated in a 2002 article titled “Dialogue with the past: the ICRC and the Nazi death camps,” that there was “no doubt that senior ICRC officials had become aware of the genocide by the summer of 1942,” and that the principal guidelines of the organization had “never been so outrageously flouted.” He continued by stating that the failure was “that of the ICRC’s inability – or unwillingness – to fully recognize the extent of the tragedy that was unfolding.” 3
In 2007, Argentina handed over a travel document issued by the ICRC that was used by Adolf Eichmann, one of the main architects of the “Final Solution,” to escape Europe after the end of the war. 2
The ICRC has also admitted that at least ten leading Nazi war criminals were able to flee capture and prosecution after the war and escape to Argentina using documentation provided by the ICRC. 4
Despite its failings during World War II, the ICRC received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1944 “for the great work it has performed during the war on behalf of humanity.” It also received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1917 and 1963. 9
During the Israel-Hamas war, the conduct of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) became a source of controversy. NGO Monitor published translations of what it described as internal Hamas documents declassified by the IDF, arguing that the documents showed ICRC to be “complicit” with Hamas. 10 ICRC personnel did not visit Israeli hostages held in Gaza; the organization’s efforts to do so, or lack thereof, became a major source of controversy. 11 Video released in October 2025 showed individuals in ICRC uniforms present during the fabrication of hostage remains to be returned to victims’ families. 12 ICRC began criticizing Israel’s response to October 7 by October 13, 2023. 13 14 The ICRC reported substantial expenditures and activities in Israel and the Palestinian territories during the war. 15
NGO Monitor published translations of internal Hamas Ministry of Interior documents dated February and March 2020 that had been uncovered and declassified by the IDF. One document stated that the ICRC “has chosen [to operate] in a wing inside Al-Shifa Hospital that is adjacent to the [Hamas] movement’s offices.” A declassified U.S. intelligence assessment later shared with the Associated Press stated that Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad used Al-Shifa and sites beneath it for command infrastructure, weapons storage, and hostage detention during the Israel-Hamas war. 16 17
As Israeli forces were in the approach to Al-Shifa, ICRC released a video on November 6 in which an ICRC legal representative stressed that hospitals are protected under international humanitarian law and that such structures should lose protected status if confirmed to be used to shield or hide militants, armaments, or operations. The representative emphasized the need to “do everything feasible to verify that it has lost its protected status.” 18 While the internal Hamas documents published by NGOMonitor suggest ICRC knew of Hamas military operation of Al-Shifa, ICRC did not disclose this information. 19 20
Under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, using humanitarian sites for military operations may constitute the war crime of human shielding, and using protected medical status to deceive enemy forces into injury or death may constitute perfidy, a war crime. 21
On November 10, 2023, five days before the IDF entered Al-Shifa Hospital, ICRC published a statement emphasizing the hospital’s protected status and the danger Israeli military action posed to civilians sheltering there. ICRC claimed that Gaza’s health-care system had reached “a point of no return” and quoted the head of its Gaza delegation saying the destruction affecting hospitals was “becoming unbearable and needs to stop.” 22
After issuing a 12-hour notice demanding that Hamas cease military activity inside Al-Shifa, the IDF entered the hospital complex on November 15, 2023. 23 The IDF found and photographed stockpiles of weapons, combat equipment, technological assets, intelligence material, an operational command center, and a fortified tunnel beneath the complex. 24 25 A declassified U.S. intelligence assessment later shared with the Associated Press stated that the U.S. Intelligence Community was “confident” and that it had independently corroborated Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad were using Al-Shifa and sites beneath it to house command infrastructure, conduct command-and-control activity, store weapons, and hold several hostages. The assessment also stated that Hamas members had evacuated the complex and destroyed sensitive documents and electronics prior to Israeli troops entering it. 26 One such hostage, 19-year-old Noa Marciano, had been taken to Al-Shifa with injuries that Israeli authorities said were not life-threatening; her father allegedly received a video of a doctor injecting her with air bubbles, killing her. 27
ICRC personnel did not visit Israeli hostages in captivity. 28 After reported refusals by the ICRC to accept medications for hostages with chronic conditions prepared by a group representing their families, 28 Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric in which he presented her with a box labeled “medication and first aid for the hostages,” and urged her to pressure Hamas. When Spoljaric said public pressure would not work because Hamas would “shut the door,” Netanyahu replied, “Why don’t you try?” 11 The next month, Israel made a deal with Qatar to deliver medication to about 45 Israeli hostages in Gaza. 29 The Associated Press reported this with the headline: “Snubbed by Netanyahu, Red Cross toes fine line trying to help civilians in Israel-Hamas conflict.” 30
Following the report’s release, the ICRC released a statement defending its actions by arguing that it could act only with the parties’ cooperation and that confidential dialogue was more effective than public pressure. 26 At the time, however, ICRC was publicly pressuring Israel; that month, Spoljaric released a statement from Gaza that the level of human suffering was “intolerable” and “unacceptable.” 31 In addition, ICRC has publicly pressed for access to persons held in other conflicts. 32 In Ukraine, after being denied access to Russian-held prisoners in 2022, the ICRC publicly demanded “immediate and unimpeded access to all prisoners of war,” said POW access was a legal obligation, and announced that an 11-person team, including a doctor, was ready in Donetsk to visit the site. 33 The next month, the organization had gained access to both Ukrainian and Russian POWs. 34 In February 2026, the ICRC director general reported the organization had visited 8,400 POWs since 2022. 35
ICRC’s website provides an overview of its efforts and impacts during the war in “Israel and the Occupied Territories: Key Facts and Figures (07 October 2023 – 31 October 2025).” Under “Monitoring treatment and conditions of detention,” it reads:
Continued to call on relevant Israeli authorities to resume informing the ICRC of the whereabouts of thousands of Palestinians held in Israeli detention, and to allow for the resumption of ICRC visits and family contacts for these detainees…Interacted with over 1,414 released detainees – through group and individual interviews – to understand their treatment and conditions of detention, informing the ICRC’s engagement with relevant authorities…Continued to engage with Hamas, calling for the unconditional release of all the hostages presumed to be remaining in Gaza, and calling for their humane treatment, access to adequate health care, ability to re-establish contact with their families, and for the ICRC to have access to them…Visited 327 detainees in 19 places of detention in the occupied Palestinian territory, one in Gaza and 18 in the West Bank, to assess and monitor their treatment and conditions of detention. 36
ICRC personnel transferred hostages in vans once released from Hamas to Israeli teams. Some social media users had compared the organization’s role to Uber. ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric later called the comparison “unacceptable and outrageous.” 37 By the war’s end, the ICRC had facilitated the release of 192 hostages, according to their own figures. 38
Scrutiny over ICRC’s involvement in hostage transfer escalated in Congress after the second round of hostage release began on February 8, 2025. Hamas had forced three emaciated hostages to make speeches on a stage to a crowd of Gazans, flanked by masked gunmen and two ICRC officials identified as Nour Khadam and Stephanie Eller, both of whom have been featured in the ICRC’s online materials. Footage from the release showed Khadam shaking hands with a Hamas militant as Eller stood behind him. 39 40 41
One of the hostages on the stage, Eli Sharabi, said he was happy he would see his wife and daughters again. After his release from 491 days of captivity, he was informed that his wife Lian and his two daughters Noya and Yahel had been murdered by Hamas on October 7. He was also informed that his brother Yossi had also been held captive and murdered after 100 days. 41
The Washington Free Beacon reported that lawmakers on Capitol Hill had “taken note” of ICRC participation in Hamas’s hostage-release ceremonies. According to senior Senate sources cited by the outlet, there was “talk of reassessing American funding to the ICRC” while officials examined the organization’s ties to Hamas. One senior Senate adviser told the Free Beacon that “Congress needs to reassess the U.S. relationship and stop any funding for any groups that have aided and abetted Hamas atrocities.” 42
In October 2025, a released IDF video showed individuals in ICRC vests standing by as masked men staged the discovery of hostage remains in Gaza City. CBS News reported that Hamas members had taken remains from a building, buried them nearby, brought them back with a bulldozer, buried them again, and then partly uncovered before organizing a staged discovery while ICRC personnel watched. 12 Hamas had been required under a ceasefire agreement to release the remains of 28 deceased hostages. 43 The ICRC later released a statement that it was present at Hamas’s request, did not know the remains had been staged before its arrival, and was unable to intervene directly on site. 44
On October 13, 2023, six days following the October 7 attacks, the ICRC released a statement criticizing Israel’s strikes against Hamas in Gaza, claiming its response to the attacks was “not compatible with international humanitarian law.” 45 Following the release, Ori Pomson, writing in Articles of War for the Lieber Institute for Law and Warfare, called the statement “extraordinary” He argued that ICRC departed from its usual practice by publicly declaring Israel’s conduct incompatible with international humanitarian law while offering little legal analysis for doing so. Pomson also argued the claim of “limitless destruction of Gaza” was factually and legally unclear. 46
A report by UN Watch analyzed ICRC posts to X (formerly Twitter) between October 6 and November 28, 2023. ICRC and its leadership posted 187 times regarding the conflict: 144 posts (77%) solely criticized Israel, 29 posts (16%) criticized both sides, and 14 Tweets (7%) criticized Hamas. 47
The ICRC’s 2024 and 2025 expenditure figures for Israel and the Palestinian territories totaled approximately CHF 261.1 million, or about $333 million. 48 49
In a facts-and-figures page covering October 7, 2023, through October 31, 2025, the ICRC’s listed activities were concentrated mainly in Gaza and the West Bank. “In support of basic needs and livelihoods in Gaza,” the page listed large-scale food, household-item, water, health, and infrastructure assistance, including aid to 2 million internally displaced persons and water-access support for more than 1.5 million people. For the West Bank, it listed livelihood and emergency assistance, including support for livestock production, agricultural development, and support for households affected by violence. For Israel, it listed support for one after-school program in Ofakim, southern Israel, and outboard engines for eight fishing households. 36
Since 1930, the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement had excluded the emergency medical service Magen David Adom (MDA; Hebrew for the Red Shield of David), founded in the British Mandate of Palestine, until it was approved in 2006. 50 51
The proximate cause for the exclusion was the MDA’s emblem, a red Shield of David (in English usually referred to as a Star of David). The Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement argued that only three emblems should be permitted: the “Red Cross,” the “Red Crescent,” and the “Red Lion-and-Sun.” The Red Cross emblem had been established by the first ICRC meeting in 1863; the Red Crescent was first used during the Russo-Turkish War in 1876-1878, and the Red Lion and Sun symbol started being used in1922 in Persia. After the First World War, the 1929 Diplomatic Conference was called to revise the Geneva Conventions. Turkish, Persian and Egyptian delegations petitioned for official recognition of the Red Crescent and the Red Lion-and-Sun, and the Conference voted to approve them. Magen David Adom was founded the following year in 1930. 50 51
After World War 2, the Diplomatic Conference convened in 1949 to revise the Geneva Conventions, and Israel proposed recognition of the Red Star of David, which was rejected. Following the Yom Kippur War, Israel proposed inclusion of MDA again in 1974 but withdrew the request without a vote due to the likely rejection of the proposal. 52 53
In 1999, then-president of the American Red Cross Bernadine Healy gave a speech in Geneva warning that MDA’s exclusion could be perceived as “partial, biased, discriminatory, or politically driven.” In response, the ICRC endorsed creating a joint working group of states and national societies to find a solution. It received criticism that the inclusion of the MDA emblem would lead to symbol proliferation, and were symbols to proliferate, they would become less immediately recognizable. 54 53
In March 2000, journalist Charles Krauthammer wrote an opinion piece in the International Herald Tribune that when Healy met privately with then-ICRC president Cornelio Sommaruga, Sommaruga made a comparison between a red Star of David and a red swastika. A representative of the ICRC published a reply letter in the Tribune, contending that the Sommaruga was referring to the swastika used in India. Healy later published a letter in The Tribune and the New York Times claiming “only after I expressed my astonishment did he invoke Sri Lanka — not India.” In the letter, she argued that the fear of symbol proliferation is a “is a pitiful fig leaf, used for decades as the reason for excluding the Magen David Adom.” 55 By May 2000, the American Red Cross began withholding $5 million in IFRC funding over the issue. 56
In September 2000, the working group had concluded on a addition of a third emblem “without political or religious connotations”: a “Red Crystal” (or rhombus). Conferences to approve the emblem were scheduled for late 2000 in Geneva by Red Cross and Red Crescent officials and Switzerland (the depositary state for the Geneva Conventions which formalizes the ICRC). That September, however, Palestinians declared the Second Intifada, and those conferences were cancelled. 50 57
The American Red Cross executive board voted the following year to continue withholding IFRC’s $5 million in annual dues until the issue was resolved. 56
By 2005, after the end of the Second Intifada, Switzerland convened a diplomatic conference to adopt the Red Crystal symbol. Israel agreed to not use a red Star of David outside of its borders and to recognize the Palestine Red Crescent Society as the relevant organization in the Palestinian territories. Contrary to previous practice, the protocol was not adopted by consensus, but by a vote requiring the necessary two-thirds majority, which ultimately succeeded. 50
Pierre Krahenbuhl has worked as director-general of the International Committee of the Red Cross since April 2024. He was previously commissioner-general and under-secretary general of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) in 2014. 58 UNRWA is a pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel refugee aid organization dedicated to serving refugees in and from the Palestinian territories. 59 60 61
Krahenbuhl resigned from his position at the UNRWA in 2019 during a misconduct inquiry that was investigating allegations that he, and other members of UNRWA leadership, abused their positions and engaged in nepotism, discrimination, and sexual misconduct, including an accusation that Krahenbuhl was having an affair with an employee. 62 63
According to Swiss media reports, Krahenbuhl created a new position, which he called a “special advisor,” and gave it to his mistress. The role was funded by the Swiss foreign affairs ministry from March 2015 to December 2018. The Swiss government temporarily froze funding to the organization, although it pledged to fund UNRWA in May 2025. 63 64
A group of U.S. Senators wrote a letter to the ICRC in March 2024 urging the organization to reconsider the appointment of Krahenbuhl as its director-general, citing the UNRWA investigation. The Senators were also concerned with the actions of the UNRWA during Krahenbuhl’s tenure, alleging that UNRWA facilities were used to store weapons of the terrorist organization Hamas. The Senators also noted that under his leadership, UNRWA textbooks contained antisemitic material. 65
The International Committee of the Red Cross lists on the “careers” version of its website that it is “committed to creating an inclusive working environment,” and that it is also committed to “ensuring fair and equitable recruitment and promotion opportunities.” The website also states that the ICRC is “committed to achieving gender parity” for management positions. 66
The International Committee of the Red Cross is a part of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, which also consists of 191 National Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies and the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. 67
The International Committee of the Red Cross receives most of its funding from governments. According to the ICRC, during the past five years, as of February 2026, government contributions make up, on average, around 82 percent of its budget. It also receives other contributions from national Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, and supranational organizations such as the European Commission, the main executive arm of the European Union (EU). 68
The organization had a total budget of CHF 2.22 billion (around $2.87 billion) in 2024, and its total expenses amounted to CHF 1.92 billion (around $2.48 billion) that year. 69